He Wins a Spot in the NYC Marathon at 70 After Just 1% of Applicants Got In, and Wants a Stress Test First. Medicare Needs Proof Something’s Wrong, Leaving Him a Bill That Can Top $1,000
New York Road Runners received a record 240,000 applications for this year’s marathon lottery, a 20% surge from 2025, and just 1% of runners who applied got in, Bloomberg reported. Picture a 70-year-old who drew one of those spots. He feels great, logs his miles and wants one more thing before race day: a cardiac stress test, just to be safe.
His doctor orders it. A few weeks later, a bill for the full price shows up. Medicare paid nothing, and his Medigap Plan G paid nothing either.
If you have chest pain, shortness of breath or a diagnosed heart condition, Medicare treats a stress test as diagnostic and pays its normal share. This trap catches healthy enrollees with no symptoms who want peace of mind before a big physical goal, such as a marathon, a trek at altitude or a hard new training plan.
Why Medicare Refuses to Pay for Peace of Mind
Part B covers diagnostic tests such as EKGs “when your provider orders them to find or treat a medical problem.” A runner who feels fine has no medical problem to find, so a stress test ordered for reassurance counts as screening. Medicare’s preventive heart benefit is narrow. It covers blood tests for cholesterol, lipid and triglyceride levels once every 5 years, and you pay nothing if your provider accepts assignment. No stress test appears on that list.
Medical guidance takes the same line. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force advises against routine screening for heart disease for people at low risk, and Choosing Wisely warns that EKGs and exercise stress tests usually aren’t necessary for people without symptoms and often produce misleading results. A false positive can lead to more testing that Medicare will happily cover, along with the worry that comes with it.
Your Supplement Follows Medicare’s Lead
Plan G pays the 20% Part B coinsurance only on claims Medicare approves. When Medicare denies a claim, the supplement denies it too. Medicare Advantage plans apply the same medical-necessity standard and often add prior authorization, so switching coverage type won’t fix this.
One Test, Two Very Different Bills
| Scenario | Patient out-of-pocket per test, 2026 |
|---|---|
| Diagnostic test (symptoms present), Original Medicare only | $283 Part B deductible, then 20% of the Medicare-approved amount |
| Diagnostic test (symptoms present), Original Medicare plus Plan G | Up to the $283 deductible if not yet met; Plan G pays the 20% |
| Screening test, freestanding imaging center (San Jose example) | $650 to $1,450 |
| Screening test, hospital (San Jose median) | $2,992 |
On a covered test performed in a hospital outpatient department, you may owe a copayment above 20%, which in most cases can’t be more than the Part A hospital stay deductible, set at $1,736 for 2026. On an uncovered test, nothing caps the bill. Some San Jose-area hospitals quote up to $6,100.
Get Cleared Without a Four-Figure Surprise
- Tell your doctor everything you’ve noticed in training. Chest pressure on hills, breathlessness out of proportion to pace, palpitations or lightheadedness are real symptoms. Reporting them turns the test into a diagnostic one that Medicare covers. Report only what you actually feel: an accurate chart protects your coverage and your health.
- Ask for an Advance Beneficiary Notice before the test. The ABN, Form CMS-R-131, tells you in writing that Medicare may deny the claim and gives an estimated cost. Choose the option that has the provider bill Medicare anyway, which keeps your right to appeal a denial. If the provider expected a denial and never gave you an ABN, the provider generally cannot bill you for the test.
- If it’s screening, shop the cash price. A plain exercise EKG costs far less than a nuclear or echo stress test. One price-comparison marketplace lists California stress tests at $331 to $774, and San Jose imaging centers quote $650 to $1,450 against a $2,992 hospital median. Get the self-pay price in writing before you schedule. Pair the test with Medicare’s free cardiovascular blood panel if you haven’t had one in the past 5 years.
Training for a marathon at 70 shows how healthy you are. Medicare pays to find out when something seems wrong, so tell your doctor exactly what you’re feeling, get the ABN before the test and know the cash price before you agree to it. Screening gaps like this one are only part of the picture, and we listed the surcharges, coverage holes and premium traps retirees keep tripping over in a free Medicare guide here.
Major Medicare Part D News (sponsor)
It might sound crazy, but Found accepts Medicare Part D for people ages 65-75, and can help users access GLP-1 medications for as little as $50/mo.
Found users can also get access to U.S.-based doctors 24/7, and could pay far less than the typical out-of-pocket cost of weight-loss medications. It’s possible to get pre-approved in as little as 2 minutes.
Take the quiz now and see how to get up to nearly 75% off weight loss medications starting at $50/month with Medicare. Read more >>
Pôvodne publikované na 247wallst.com