Tweetko
11-day Bitcoin redemption freeze: the risk hiding inside BTC-backed tokens

11-day Bitcoin redemption freeze: the risk hiding inside BTC-backed tokens

InvestingLive
InvestingLive
Verified Page
4 min read
0
Comments
0
Views

At around 4,185 tokens, tBTC is far too small to move the BTC price, and the pause caused no visible spillover into spot Bitcoin, ETH or crypto equities. The pressure fell on DeFi lending. With redemption shut, liquidators taking tBTC collateral on Aave couldn’t fall back on redemption arbitrage, so they carried price and timing risk until they found a buyer. WBTC, cbBTC and other Bitcoin-backed tokens also depend on a bridge or custodian to keep minting and redemption open. Risk teams may now price that dependency into collateral settings more explicitly.

---

It was a heavy day for crypto:

---

Threshold never ran short of Bitcoin, but for 11 days its token holders couldn’t get any of it back.

Summary:

  • Threshold Network suspended tBTC redemptions from Oct. 30 to Nov. 10. Its Nov. 18 post-mortem calls it an operational and security failure, not a reserve shortfall.
  • Bridge wallets held about 4,320 BTC against roughly 4,185 tBTC in circulation, a surplus of around 135 BTC.
  • There were two causes: a fault in how the bridge accounted for deposits, and a security issue tied to a Linux kernel flaw that took some signing operators offline. Each wallet needs a majority of its signers to move funds.
  • The Council restored Bitcoin proof submissions on Nov. 7. The app reopened at about 03:00 UTC on Nov. 10.
  • A review of 57 wallet addresses matched 31 redemption payouts to bridge proofs and found no unexplained outflows.
  • Aave froze its tBTC reserve on Ethereum V3 Core on Oct. 31. The reserve held about $136 million at the start of the freeze and about $120 million later.

Threshold Network kept tBTC holders from swapping their tokens back into native Bitcoin for 11 days, from Oct. 30 to Nov. 10, even though its bridge wallets held more Bitcoin than the tokens it had issued. The project’s post-mortem, published on Nov. 18, describes an operational and security failure rather than a shortfall in reserves.

On Oct. 31, Threshold reported roughly 4,320 BTC in its bridge wallets against about 4,185 tBTC in circulation, a cushion of around 135 BTC. That surplus did not help anyone who wanted out. The app stopped accepting redemption requests after unexpected bridge activity raised security concerns, and two separate problems then kept it shut.

The first was a fault in how the bridge accounted for incoming Bitcoin deposits, which the team said it identified before the suspension. The second was a security issue, linked in earlier updates to a critical Linux kernel flaw, that forced some of the node operators who sign Bitcoin transactions to patch their servers or take them offline. Because every bridge wallet needs signatures from more than half of its designated signers, withdrawals could not move until enough operators returned. Permission to submit Bitcoin proofs, which the bridge uses to verify deposits and redemption payouts, was also suspended, blocking the process at a second point.

Threshold said it fixed the accounting issue and upgraded the bridge before its Council restored proof submissions on Nov. 7. The app reopened at around 03:00 UTC on Nov. 10. A review of 57 registered wallet addresses and the bridge contracts, covering Oct. 25 to Nov. 12, matched 31 Bitcoin redemption payouts to their bridge proofs and found no unexplained outflows. Separately, one operator reported an unrelated infrastructure incident in which about 0.5 ETH left the Ethereum account it used for tBTC fees.

The episode spilled into lending. Aave froze its tBTC reserve on the Ethereum V3 Core market on Oct. 31, blocking new deposits and borrowing against the token while still allowing repayments, withdrawals and liquidations. The reserve held about $136 million when the freeze began and around $120 million by the time the bridge restarted.

The wider point for anyone holding Bitcoin in token form is that reserves and redemption are separate promises. A proof-of-reserves snapshot can show the coins exist, but getting them back depends on signers, software and governance all working at once. Readers should watch whether Aave lifts its reserve freeze, whether tBTC keeps trading close to Bitcoin now redemptions are open, and whether other Bitcoin-backed tokens publish clearer plans for keeping exits open during security emergencies. 

This article was written by Eamonn Sheridan at investinglive.com.

Pôvodne publikované na investinglive.com