Tweetko
His Estate Said the Divorce Canceled His Ex-Wife’s Claim To His $373,000 Boeing 401(k). A Washington Appeals Court Disagreed. Here’s What Every 401(k) Holder Needs To Know About Beneficiary Designation

His Estate Said the Divorce Canceled His Ex-Wife’s Claim To His $373,000 Boeing 401(k). A Washington Appeals Court Disagreed. Here’s What Every 401(k) Holder Needs To Know About Beneficiary Designation

24/7 Wall St.
24/7 Wall St.
Verified Page
5 min read
0
Comments
0
Views

Stephanie and Kevin Miller married in 2013 and divorced in 2019, according to a Washington Court of Appeals opinion. Kevin died without a will in April 2023. Kevin had a 401(k) through Boeing (NYSE:BA), and Fidelity Workplace Services LLC managed the plan.

The Kevin’s estate argued that the divorce invalidated Stephanie’s claim to the retirement account.

The Washington Court of Appeals opinion disagreed,  stating that “The dissolution decree did not address Kevin’s retirement plan” and that “Stephanie was not removed as the beneficiary of the retirement plan after the divorce.”

 

How the Estate Won at Trial and Lost on Appeal

Keith D. Miller, the personal representative of Kevin’s estate, sued Stephanie for unjust enrichment. He argued that Washington’s divorce-revocation statute ended her beneficiary status when the marriage ended. The trial court agreed. It granted summary judgment for the estate and required Stephanie to pay the money from the retirement plan disbursement to Keith.

Division II reversed in an unpublished opinion filed June 23, 2026. Judge Maxa wrote it, and Acting Chief Judge Price and Judge Che agreed. “The law is clear under Egelhoff and Estate of Lundy that ERISA preempts [Washington’s divorce-revocation statute],” the court wrote. Its ruling: “We reverse the trial court’s grant of summary judgment in favor of Keith and remand with instructions to enter judgment in favor of Stephanie.”

The panel found fault with the lawyers on both sides. “Apparently, Keith’s counsel was unaware of the controlling law,” the opinion says, and “Stephanie’s counsel also apparently was ignorant of the law.” Because the opinion is unpublished, it carries no precedential weight in Washington. The federal rule behind it has been settled for decades.

The sources disagree about when Stephanie was named. The opinion says “The beneficiary designation appears to state that it was entered in January 2022, after Kevin and Stephanie’s divorce.” A Stokes Lawrence client alert by Kristen Fisher says Kevin named her “During their marriage and before the divorce.” The court summed up Stephanie’s position as saying he still listed her when he retired early in 2020. Under the court’s reasoning, the date never had to be determined. Federal law displaced the state statute either way.

Event Date
Egelhoff v. Egelhoff decided 2001
Kennedy v. DuPont plan decided 2009
Kevin and Stephanie marry 2013
Divorce 2019
Date on the designation form, per the opinion (uncertain) January 2022
Kevin dies April 2023
Appeals court opinion filed June 23, 2026

Two Supreme Court Rulings That Put the Plan Form First

In Egelhoff v. Egelhoff (2001), the facts look much like this case: a Boeing employee and a Washington divorce. The Supreme Court concluded “that the Washington statute has a ‘connection with’ ERISA plans and is therefore pre-empted.” ERISA is the federal law that governs most employer retirement plans.

A Crowell & Moring client alert says the Supreme Court issued a 9-0 decision in Kennedy v. Plan Administrator for DuPont Savings and Investment Plan. The plan’s beneficiary form controlled even though the ex-wife had given up her claim in the divorce decree. The firm wrote: “The Court noted that ERISA requires that a plan administrator act solely in accordance with plan documents,” and “The Court thus found that the plan administrator did his duty by paying benefits to Liv, in accordance with the beneficiary designation.”

Where IRAs Can Follow Different Rules

As quoted in Egelhoff, Washington’s statute covers nonprobate assets including “a life insurance policy, employee benefit plan, annuity or similar contract, or individual retirement account.” ERISA overrides that only for ERISA plans. Stokes Lawrence notes that “ERISA governs many employer-sponsored retirement plans, including most 401(k) plans.”

Most 401(k)s fall under ERISA, though some do not. State divorce-revocation laws can still apply to IRAs and other non-ERISA assets, and those rules vary by state. Beneficiary forms, account ownership, and outdated paperwork are exactly the cleanup items we walked through in a free estate checklist, since a missed form often decides more than a will does.

The beneficiary form also controls the tax result. For owners who die after 2019, the SECURE Act requires the entire balance of the participant’s account be distributed within ten years. Exceptions cover a surviving spouse and a few other groups. An ex-spouse usually inherits on that ten-year timeline and owes ordinary income tax on every pretax dollar withdrawn.

Three Checks to Make on Your Own 401(k)

  1. Review the form after every major life event. Stokes Lawrence writes: “For individuals, the lesson is equally clear: beneficiary designations should be reviewed and updated following major life events, particularly divorce, remarriage, or the birth of children.”
  2. Don’t rely on your will or divorce decree to change the form. “Wills and trusts are important, but they do not necessarily control assets that pass by beneficiary designation,” the firm writes. If the divorce decree is silent, as Kevin’s was, the form on file decides who gets the account.
  3. Ask the plan for a copy of the designation on file. Request the form itself. Check the names, the date and any contingent beneficiaries. If you’re going through a divorce or settling a parent’s estate, talk to an estate or family-law attorney before the plan pays anyone.

Released: 401k & IRA Tips and Answers

(sponsor) 401(k)s are powerful retirement tools. But even savvy savers can make mistakes that quietly cost you money for decades. Choosing the wrong fund, ignoring small fees nobody adds up, rollover steps done in the wrong order, the list goes on.

These sort of mistakes is exactly what 401k & IRA Tips and Answers was created to help prevent. It is a free guide from Fisher Investments on rollovers, contributions, required withdrawals and the mistakes that do the most damage to a retirement account. Learn More Here ›

Pôvodne publikované na 247wallst.com