Tweetko

He’s Trading New York for Tennessee Mountains as Couples Split Over City vs Country Retirement. Either Way, a Federal Law Shields His $60,000 401(k) Withdrawal From New York Tax

24/7 Wall St.
Doğrulanmış sayfa
5 dk okuma
0
Yorumlar
2
Görüntülenme

A 66-year-old Manhattan retired person has $1.2 million in a 401(k). He plans to take $60,000 a year from it once he and his wife buy a few acres outside Knoxville. She wants to stay in the city. He worries that Albany will keep taxing his withdrawals because he earned and deferred that money while working in New York.

Couples fight about this all the time. A Washington Post advice column published Nov. 14 ran under the headline “Spouse wants to move ‘city mouse’ to a rural retirement.” On taxes at least, his fear has no basis.

A 1996 Federal Law Puts His 401(k) Out of New York’s Reach

Federal law, 4 U.S.C. § 114(a), states: “No State may impose an income tax on any retirement income of an individual who is not a resident or domiciliary of such State.” The first item on the statute’s list of retirement income is money from a qualified trust under section 401(a), and that category covers every 401(k).

The statute’s “substantially equal periodic payments” test applies only to nonqualified deferred compensation and payments to retired partners. That means a 401(k) withdrawal of any size, taken on any schedule, is protected. New York’s tax department says the same thing: pension income received while a nonresident “is not taxed by New York State” and stays out of the New York column on Form IT-203.

Tennessee doesn’t tax it either. The state’s Hall tax on interest and dividends was repealed for tax years beginning January 1, 2021. Plenty of New Yorkers have made the same move. IRS migration data show 3,817 New York tax returns moved to Tennessee in the 2022 to 2023 period, carrying about $346 million in income.

Prices are lower too: on a cost-of-living index where 100 is the national average, Tennessee scores about 92 and New York about 134.

Two Mistakes That Hand New York Its Claim Back

The protection only works if he is a nonresident under New York’s own definition. The state treats anyone who keeps a permanent place of abode there and spends more than 183 days of the year in the state as a resident, wherever his legal residence is (N.Y. Tax Law § 605(b)(1)(B)). Say his wife keeps the apartment and he splits his time. A residency audit could then put the full $60,000 back on a New York return.

The second mistake is about timing. In the year he moves, he files as a part-year resident, so any withdrawal taken before the move date counts as New York income. A withdrawal taken the week after the move is outside New York’s reach.

Federal Taxes on Social Security Come Along to Tennessee

Leaving New York doesn’t change the federal math. Assume, as an example, the couple collects $40,000 a year in Social Security. Their provisional income is the $60,000 withdrawal plus half of their benefits, which comes to $80,000.

That’s well above the $44,000 joint threshold in 26 U.S.C. § 86(c)(2)(B), so the maximum 85% of benefits, or $34,000, becomes taxable. Their federal gross income hits $94,000 before deductions.

Medicare surcharges don’t come into play at this income. In 2026, the Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount (IRMAA) surcharge starts above $218,000 of joint income, and below that each spouse pays the standard $203 a month for Part B. That leaves a lot of room for Roth conversions.

He has time, too: anyone born in 1960 or later doesn’t face required distributions until age 75.

Moves to Make Before the Truck Arrives

  1. Give up the New York home or track every day spent there. If the couple keeps the city apartment, he needs a dated log showing he stays at or under the 183-day line. Move his driver’s license, voter registration, doctors and safe deposit box to Tennessee in the same year he moves. New York auditors check where those ties are.
  2. Take withdrawals and Roth conversions after the move date. A conversion counts as a distribution from the 401(k)’s qualified trust, so conversions done after he becomes a Tennessee resident owe no state tax. Keep joint income under $218,000, and remember that Medicare looks back two years. A conversion at 66 sets the premium bill at 68.
  3. Roll part of the 401(k) into an IRA before 70½. Qualified charitable distributions (QCDs) come only from IRAs, and the 2026 limit is $111,000 per person. Giving through a QCD lowers provisional income, which reduces the taxable share of Social Security. Since 401(k) RMDs must be taken separately from each plan, combining old plans into one IRA also makes later withdrawals simpler.

Released: 401k & IRA Tips and Answers

(sponsor) 401(k)s are powerful retirement tools. But even savvy savers can make mistakes that quietly cost you money for decades. Choosing the wrong fund, ignoring small fees nobody adds up, rollover steps done in the wrong order, the list goes on.

These sort of mistakes is exactly what 401k & IRA Tips and Answers was created to help prevent. It is a free guide from Fisher Investments on rollovers, contributions, required withdrawals and the mistakes that do the most damage to a retirement account. Learn More Here ›